Financial Results
AM Best: US Mutual Insurers Doubled Net Income in 2025
Total net income for U.S. property/casualty mutual insurers doubled compared to 2024 to about $42.6 billion in 2025 as underwriting income surged to about $14.8 billion from a loss of $7.2 billion in 2024.
According to a recent AM Best report on the segment, the rise in net income was also driven by a modest 2% decline in loss and loss adjustment expenses despite underwriting expenses increasing 5.8% in 2025 compared to the year prior.
“Mutuals began filing for significant rate increases, restructuring discounts and raising deductibles in years preceding 2025, and the effects of these underwriting actions have bolstered revenue,” said Justin Aimone, financial analyst, AM Best. “Rate adequacy and mutual carriers’ ability to properly price risks also have benefited significantly from the rise of data analytics, enhanced technology and risk modeling.”
News
Small Commercial Competition Intensifies as Insurers Extend Reach Across a $158 Billion Market
Small commercial insurance has become an increasingly important growth market for property-casualty insurers, but the opportunity is far from uniform.
As insurers extend their reach, differences in account economics, underwriting complexity and distribution needs are creating new strategic and competitive challenges, according to Conning's study, Small Commercial Insurance Market: Insurers Extend Their Reach.
"The scale of the small commercial market is compelling, but the defining challenge is not simply reaching more businesses," said Jay Sarzen, a Director in Conning Insurance Research and author of the study. "Insurers need to determine which segments align with their capabilities, make it easier for agents to place the right risks, and use technology in ways that improve speed and consistency while preserving necessary judgment."
Research
Big ‘I’ and Future One Release 2026 Agency Universe Study
The Big ‘I’ and Future One released the 2026 Agency Universe Study, which found revenue growth, technology adoption and a focus on customer service.
The vast majority of independent insurance agencies report profitability across both personal and commercial lines, with significantly fewer reporting revenue decreases compared to 2024, according to the 2026 Agency Universe Study.
Meanwhile, amid growing adoption of artificial intelligence (AI), independent agents are increasingly investing in marketing, hiring and emphasizing value rather than price.
Announcements
Aon introduces new diagnostics for property and casualty risk analysis - Reinsurance News
Aon, a global professional services firm specialising in risk, insurance, retirement and health solutions, has introduced two new consulting-led diagnostic tools aimed at helping organisations assess property and casualty exposures and use risk data to inform investment and insurance decisions.
The Property Risk Diagnostic and Casualty Risk Diagnostic are designed to give risk and finance teams a more structured view of their exposures, allowing them to examine loss drivers, assess potential mitigation measures and monitor changes over time. Aon said the tools are intended to provide a consistent evidence base for decisions on resilience, risk management and insurance strategy.
“Clients are asking a sharper question than a few years ago: not just what their risk is, but what to do about it and what it is worth,” commented Christian Hoffman, CEO of Commercial Risk, Aon. “Our Property Risk Diagnostic and Casualty Risk Diagnostic are two distinct tools built for two distinct problems, but they share the same purpose: giving risk and finance leaders an evidence base they can act on with confidence.”
One Inc Launches XpressOne™ to Accelerate Claims Resolution Through Vendor Payments Innovation
One Inc, the leading digital payments network for the insurance industry, already connects more than 1.3 million vendors and providers with over 320 carriers. Today it launched XpressOne™, a major enhancement to that network. Vendors and providers now have the option to join XpressOne for faster payments and simpler reconciliation, with features that include self-service payment management, automated routing by location, carrier or TIN, custom reporting and real-time visibility.
XpressOne is purpose-built for the complex workflows of insurance. For vendors who receive payments from many carriers across numerous locations and tax identification numbers (TINs), it replaces a fragmented, high-friction process with a single, connected experience that gives them more control with far less manual work. Two payment modalities make funds arrive even faster: XpressOne ClaimsCard, a flexible card-based option, and XpressOne Direct, which deposits funds straight into the vendor’s bank account. Support for RTP and FedNow is coming soon.
Telematics, Driving & Insurance
Arity Introduces Arity Lead Platform, Giving Insurers Greater Control Over Customer Acquisition
Arity, a mobility data and analytics company, today introduced Arity Lead Platform, an insurance-native, carrier-controlled platform designed to help insurers drive growth, increase control over acquisition decisions and investments, and better understand what drives long-term business value.
Insurance carriers invest heavily across publishers, marketplaces, lead and call providers, agency networks, CRM platforms, and distribution channels. Yet the systems supporting those investments often operate independently, fragmenting acquisition decisions and limiting visibility from acquisition spend through customer outcomes. As carriers face increasing pressure to drive efficiency and profitable growth, understanding which acquisition investments create value has become increasingly important.
"Customer acquisition has become too important to manage as a series of disconnected decisions," said Gary Hallgren, President of Arity. "Carriers have an opportunity to outperform by connecting acquisition activity to business outcomes and using what they learn to improve acquisition performance. Arity Lead Platform puts carriers at the center, giving them control over how acquisition decisions are made across their ecosystem and helping them turn more of their investment into long-term value."
AI in Insurance
AI AS A FRAUD AND RISK MANAGEMENT TOOL - The Rough Notes Company Inc.
Looking for “rights” and “wrongs” in the AI future. [O]ur inner critic often keeps us in one place, feeling both stagnant and frustrated, but also safe and predictable. It’s a relationship worth exploring—and challenging—if that feels right for you. - Alan Demers
Artificial Intelligence (AI) now permeates business and daily life as a tool, a substitute for humans, or a subject of experimentation. This landscape is fraught with contradiction, making it difficult to untangle hype from reality. The argument over whether AI will replace human jobs or create new ones illustrates just one area of ambiguity. Billions of dollars of AI investments from energy production, data centers, and the likes of Anthropic’s revenue curve speak volumes about demand and adoption.
Sizing up the state of AI in property/casualty insurance is similarly challenging, with many debating if AI is a tool or if it is transformational. Perhaps the proper answer is “both.” More nuanced answers involve when, how much, and to what degree, all of which are (or should be) tied to return on investment (ROI). Either way, AI tools apply across the entire insurance value lifecycle, including risk management and combating fraud.
Deploying agentic AI to operate as an insurance agent, however, is even more debatable, despite its use in today’s insurance sales process. Some go so far as to tout an AI quote-and-bind. CONTINUES
Thimble and Bold Penguin Launch AI-Powered Insurance Quoting
Thimble and Bold Penguin launched an AI-powered integration to make small business insurance quoting faster and more efficient.
This technology links the two platforms, letting AI agents share information and help with quoting and binding through automated workflows.
The target is to cut down on repetitive tasks for insurance professionals and promote brokers involved in chief customer and coverage decisions. It shows the insurance industry's growing interest in using AI to boost efficiency while keeping people in control. By bringing these platforms together, the integration could make it easier for brokers, insurers, and small business customers to work together.
West Bend Lays the Foundation for AI-Driven Claims on Guidewire
West Bend Insurance Company and Guidewire (NYSE: GWRE) today announced that West Bend is successfully running its claims operations on Guidewire Cloud.
This implementation elevates service quality and decision-making across all lines of business while establishing the reliable data foundation required to scale AI across West Bend's claims operations.
"Connecting our reliable data directly to live workflows is what makes AI in claims management possible," said Murali Natarajan, senior vice president and chief information officer, West Bend. "By embedding analytics directly into the daily workflow, we can improve indemnity accuracy and deliver optimized claims service to our policyholders. That foundation enables us to build a system that learns from every closed claim to improve how we process the next."
Predict & Prevent
Why Connected Property Data Matters After the Home is Built
Smart home adoption is rising, but data stays siloed after closing, limiting risk pricing, service and retention.
A homeowner in suburban Atlanta closed on a new build last spring. Within six months, she had a smart thermostat from the HVAC contractor who did her tune-up, a leak sensor her insurance agent recommended, a video doorbell she bought herself and a garage door opener the builder threw in at closing.
Four devices, four apps, four service relationships and no communication between any of them. When her water heater failed in October, none of it helped her find a plumber, and none of the professionals who had touched the home since closing knew anything about the others.
YouGov’s 2024 US Smart Home Trend Report found 65% of Americans now own at least one smart home device, up from 51% in 2020. A 2026 synthesis of RubyHome, Mordor Intelligence and Statista data puts roughly 77 million U.S. homes on smart-home devices. Adoption has crossed a threshold. The infrastructure hasn’t.
Fraud
GEICO says two DME companies ran $1.9M phantom-billing scheme
What happened: GEICO alleges two DME shell companies billed $1.9 million for medically unnecessary equipment prescribed to fender-bender victims through forged prescriptions
Who's involved: GEICO (plaintiff) against two DME supply companies and their listed owners
What's at stake: More than $666,000 already paid, plus $952,000 in pending claims GEICO wants declared void
Why it matters: The filing maps a playbook for rotating shell DME entities to evade insurer scrutiny under New York No-Fault
Where it stands: Complaint filed September 28, 2026; no response on record ARTICLE
People
The Hartford Announces CEO Succession
The Hartford’s Board of Directors has named company President A. Morris “Mo” Tooker to succeed Christopher Swift as its next CEO. Swift will transition to the role of executive chair of the board. Both appointments are effective March 1, 2027. In addition, Tooker will join the board, effective Oct. 1, 2026.
“This thoughtful succession plan ensures a seamless transition, preserving strategic continuity, business momentum and operational strength,” said Trevor Fetter, lead independent director of The Hartford’s Board of Directors. “Respected throughout the insurance industry, Mo combines strategic vision with disciplined execution. He has consistently delivered profitable growth, advanced customer-centered innovation, upheld underwriting rigor and built strong, aligned teams. He is ideally suited to lead as CEO and guide The Hartford’s next chapter.”